 |
 NEW Wirebound 1 Subject Blue Kraft College Margin Ru $1.99 Time Remaining: 14d 21h 21m Buy It Now for only: $1.99 |
 Smead Six Section Hanging Classification Folder Pressboard Kraft Letter Blue $9.99 Time Remaining: 14d 15h 49m Buy It Now for only: $9.99 |
 Rediform Wirebound 1 Subject Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 9 1 2 x 6 80 $9.20 Time Remaining: 27d 13h 14m Buy It Now for only: $9.20 |
 Rediform Wirebound 1 Subject Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 7 3 4 x 5 80 $8.97 Time Remaining: 27d 13h 14m Buy It Now for only: $8.97 |
 TOPS Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 9 x 11 White 50 Sheets Pad $9.85 Time Remaining: 28d 11h 20m Buy It Now for only: $9.85 |
 Smead Six Section Hanging Classification Folder Pressboard Kraft Legal Blue $10.99 Time Remaining: 13d 11h 51m Buy It Now for only: $10.99 |
 Rediform Wirebound 1 Subject Blue Kraft College Margin Ruled Notebook 11x8 1 2 $10.22 Time Remaining: 5d 8h 27m Buy It Now for only: $10.22 |
 Pacon 63180 Rainbow Duo Finish Dark Blue Kraft Paper 35 lbs 36in x 1000 ft $78.99 Time Remaining: 17d 17h 38m Buy It Now for only: $78.99 |
 Pacon Creative Products Rainbow Kraft Roll 100ft Sky Blue PAC66151 $23.99 Time Remaining: 12d 2h 46m Buy It Now for only: $23.99 |
 Four Section Hanging Classification Folder Pressboard Kraft Legal Blue $9.01 Time Remaining: 13d 8h 34m Buy It Now for only: $9.01 |
 Tops 65120 Blue Kraft Notebook 7 Item Bundle Wirebound Notebooks TOP65 $20.89 Time Remaining: 3d 15h 21m Buy It Now for only: $20.89 |
 Pendaflex 4152X2BLU 2 Inch Reinforced Hanging Kraft File Folders Blue 2 $70.99 Time Remaining: 26d 18h 15m Buy It Now for only: $70.99 |
 Tops 65119 Blue Kraft Notebook 7 Item Bundle Wirebound Notebooks TOP65 $19.63 Time Remaining: 3d 12h 30m Buy It Now for only: $19.63 |
 Pacon Creative Products Rainbow Kraft Roll 100ft Blue PAC66161 $22.99 Time Remaining: 12d 29m Buy It Now for only: $22.99 |
 Pendaflex 2 Capacity Reinforced Hanging File Folders Kraft Letter Blue $29.39 Time Remaining: 1d 10h 12m Buy It Now for only: $29.39 |
 Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 9 x 11 White 50 Sheets Pad TOP65120 $4.69 Time Remaining: 6d 6h 46m Buy It Now for only: $4.69 |
 Tops 65119 Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 5 x 7 3 4 White 80 Sheets Pad 6 $24.99 Time Remaining: 17d 18h 39m Buy It Now for only: $24.99 |
 Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 5 x 7 3 4 White 80 Sheets Pad TOP65119 $3.67 Time Remaining: 26d 22h 35m Buy It Now for only: $3.67 |
 Tops 65120 Blue Kraft Notebook College Rule 9 x 11 White 50 Sheets Pad 6 Ea $27.99 Time Remaining: 17d 17h 36m Buy It Now for only: $27.99 |
 Pendaflex Reinforced Hanging File Folders Kraft Legal Blue 25 Box $25.23 Time Remaining: 1d 10h 12m Buy It Now for only: $25.23 |
 Pacon 63200 Royal Blue Rainbow Duo Finish Colored Kraft Paper $94.99 Time Remaining: 17d 17h 30m Buy It Now for only: $94.99 |
 Pacon 63150 Sky Blue Rainbow Duo Finish Colored Kraft Paper $92.99 Time Remaining: 17d 17h 58m Buy It Now for only: $92.99 |
 Pendaflex Reinforced Hanging File Folders Kraft Letter Blue 25 Box $22.51 Time Remaining: 1d 10h 12m Buy It Now for only: $22.51 |
 Pacon 63170 Bright Blue Rainbow Duo Finish Colored Kraft Paper $93.99 Time Remaining: 17d 18h 13m Buy It Now for only: $93.99 |
 Four Section Hanging Classification Folder Pressboard Kraft Letter Blue $8.70 Time Remaining: 13d 11h 51m Buy It Now for only: $8.70 |
 CKC 988210 2 Chenille Kraft Student Dry Erase Boards 12 x 9 Blue White $70.99 Time Remaining: 27d 14h 53m Buy It Now for only: $70.99 |
 Pacon Creative Products Rainbow Kraft Roll 100 Ft Dark Blue PAC66181 $22.99 Time Remaining: 17d 21h 33m Buy It Now for only: $22.99 |
 NEW ESSELTE 74502 Recycled Hanging File Folders Kraft Letter Blue 25 Box $32.19 Time Remaining: 17d 22h 8m Buy It Now for only: $32.19 |
 Rainbow Colored Kraft Paper Smooth Duo Finish 36 x 1000 Royal Blue $75.38 Time Remaining: 26d 21h 32m Buy It Now for only: $75.38 |
 Recycled Hanging File Folders Kraft Letter Blue 25 per Box $19.99 Time Remaining: 20d 12h 40m Buy It Now for only: $19.99 |
 Pacon Creative Products Rainbow Kraft Roll 100ft Brite Blue PAC66171 $22.99 Time Remaining: 12d 3h 2m Buy It Now for only: $22.99 |
 2 Capacity Reinforced Hanging File Folders Kraft Letter Blue 25 per Box $23.99 Time Remaining: 20d 12h 37m Buy It Now for only: $23.99 |
 NEW ESSELTE 76502 Recycled Hanging File Folders Kraft Legal Blue 25 Box $41.05 Time Remaining: 2d 21h 55m Buy It Now for only: $41.05 |
 Rainbow Colored Kraft Paper Smooth Duo Finish 36 x 1000 Roll Dk Blue $53.98 Time Remaining: 6d 17h 56m Buy It Now for only: $53.98 |
 Recycled Hanging File Folders Kraft Legal Blue 25 per Box $26.99 Time Remaining: 20d 12h 40m Buy It Now for only: $26.99 |
 FastFold Tie Close Box Letter 15 x 24 x 10 Kraft Blue 12 Carton $99.99 Time Remaining: 27d 3h 19m Buy It Now for only: $99.99 |
 Rainbow Colored Kraft Paper Smooth Duo Finish 36 x 1000 Roll Lt Blue $68.99 Time Remaining: 26d 22h 22m Buy It Now for only: $68.99 |
Blue Kraft
What Constitutes Misleading Similarity When Packaging Competing Products? The Court Rules On Sandwich Cookies
Adv. Gill Nadel, Keydar Hallaly
Recently, the court dismissed a petition filed by the manufacturer and marketer of Oreo cookies to forbid an importer marketing Go Go's brand cookies from marketing them, as they were misleadingly similar to Oreo cookies and therefore deceiving to the public. The court dismissed this on the grounds that there was no misleading similarity between the packaging and therefore no risk of deception.
The claims of the parties:
The claims of the foreign manufacturer:
The manufacturer claimed that the importer designed the Go Go's sandwich cookies' packaging in such a way that intend to mislead consumers into thinking that the product was related to Oreo cookies as an additional product from the manufacturer's line of products, or as an associated product to this line. Thus, he claimed, the importer attempted to take advantage of his products' well known reputation and pass them off as his own while violating a well-recognized trademark.
The manufacturer claimed that the Oreo sandwich cookies which it manufactures are packed in a special package with a unique print that make it stand out from other sandwich cookies on the market. Further more, the manufacturer claimed that the Go Go cookies' packages look almost exactly the same as the Oreo cookies' famous package. According to the manufactor's claim, the similarity was partially owed to the combination of colors used on the package and the picture of the black sandwich cookies with splashes of milk in the background.
The manufacturer further claimed that in a consumer survey conducted among around 500 participants between the ages of 12-70 (whom, to his words, served as a representative national sample), over 36% of the respondents believed the Go Go cookies were associated with the Oreo cookies, and that this proves the risk of deception.
In light of this, the manufacturer requested that the court oblige the importer in damages of one million shekels, order that the imported products be destroyed, and forbid the continuation of their marketing. The action was also filed against Diplomat, the product distributor.
The importer's claim:
In opposition, it was claimed by the importer that there is no misleading similarity between the manufacturer's packaging design and that of his imported goods, since the size of the package was different and also unlike the manufacturer's claim, the color of the package was completely different. The importer further claimed that there is nothing unique in the manufacturer's packaging design since both in Israel and around the world, other brands of cookies are sold in rectangular packages including- , an illustration of the cookies, the use of the color blue, the picture of the splashing milk, etc. The importer also claimed that ever since it began marketing the Go Go cookies, not a single complaint was received by a consumer on the count of purchasing this brand by mistake instead of the manufacturer's cookies. Regarding the action against Diplomat, the importer? claimed that it was merely a distribution company and thus it had nothing to do with this case and any how there was no cause action against it.
The Decision:
The court rejected the manufacturer's claimed and ruled that there was no misleading similarity between the appearance of the packages and based this, inter alia, on the fact that the dominant color of the manufacturer's packaging design was blue, where as the importer's was purple. Additionally, it was ruled that the dominant component used in the manufacturer's advertisements and commercials was the symbol "OREO" and even on the Oreo cookies' packages, the symbol OREO was a prominent feature. Therefore, it was ruled that the weight of the decision should be given to the fact that there was no similarity between the symbol "OREO" and the symbol "GO-GO'S" which stands out on the importer's Go-Go's cookies. Additionally, the court attributed importance to the fact that the importer's package was significantly bigger than that of the manufacturer.
The court accepted the importer's claims and ruled that since an illustration or picture of similar sandwich cookies appears on a variety of packages of similar products, it cannot be ruled that having such an illustration on the importer's package creates a risk of deception. Regarding the consumer survey conducted by the manufacturer, the court ruled that the results of the survey indicate of the reputation that the Oreo brand has among the relevant consumers, but does not indicate of "a real potential risk of deception from (competing) products".
In light of this, the court ruled that there was no misleading similarity between the packages of the importer and the packages of the manufacturer, and that there is no risk that the relevant consumer population will be misled into thinking that the importer's cookies are those of the manufacturers' or associated to them.
Therefore, the court dismissed the action and obliged the manufacturer in legal expenses plus attorneys' fees of 40,000 NIS, towards the importer and the distribution company jointly.
(CA (District Tel Aviv) 20277-09-10 Kraft Foods Global Brands LLC v. Y. Marbeh Israel Ltd et al, Judge Yehuda Zeft, issued 27.12.10. Advocates: Kraft was represented by Adv. L. Watstein, S. Israel, and K. Ben-Shachar. Y. Marbeh was represented by Adv. A. Shaulski. Diplomat was represented by Adv. H. Cohen-Haramati.)
About the Author
Gill Nadel - Born in Israel in 1969, graduated from Bar Ilan University`s Faculty of Law (cum laude) and from the Department of Musicology. He also has a master`s degree in law from the same institution. Member of the Israel Bar since 1999. Speaks Hebrew, English and Polish. Fields of expertise: Commercial and Business Law, International Trade Law, Import and Export Law, Intellectual Property Law, Maritime and International Forwarding Law, Litigation and Court Representation. Adv. Nadel provides lectures on international trade law and import and export law to in courses organized by the Bar Ilan University Center for Commercial Law, Israel Bar, Israel Chambers of Commerce, Manufacturers Association of Israel, Israel Export Institute, Customs Brokers Association, International Forwarders, and more.
Favorite store brand of mac & cheese?
Of course home made is probably the best, but if we're talking about buying off the shelf:
I love Kraft (blue box) and I've also had Michelina's. Never tried Velveeta...
So what's your favorite and why would you rate it #1?
I went on a Velveeta kick awhile back because I loved the texture of the shells- but I got very tired of the velveeta itself.
Now I love the blue box because I can add things to the sauce to make it even better.
Mini Dedicated to Stella Blue Kraft (RIP)